A Monarch Dethroned

02 October 2017 / by John Grant

It is never good news when an airline collapses, especially one with such history and a strong brand but when an airline does collapse, there is inevitably a lot of discussion around why it happened and sometimes it’s good to look purely at the data to see what changed.

In terms of capacity offered, over the last five years there has been very little change in capacity, as the table below highlights. In fact, of the five-year period, the difference in capacity provided by Monarch was less than 200 seats – or just one flight! However, its share of the market fell from 4.6% to 3.7%, as airlines such as easyJet, Ryanair and Norwegian grew their capacity.

Table 1 - UK & Ireland Domiciled Airline Capacity, UK to Europe

monarch-table1.jpgSource: OAG Schedules Analyser

Losing market share for any business is worrying, and clearly a result of pressures on yield that have already been noted by analysts. For Monarch, the changes that occurred in its markets may have been just a step too far as Table 2 below illustrates.

In the last four years, a mix of terrorist activity, travel bans and consumer confidence impacted Monarch probably harder than any other UK-based airline. Some 213,000 seats were no longer offered to Egypt whilst Turkey saw capacity fall by another 100,000 seats. Redirecting that capacity to markets such as Spain and Portugal may have been the only option available but those two markets already well served by market leading low-cost carriers placed Monarch in a far more competitive market than they probably wanted with yields falling very quickly.

Table 2 – Monarch Airlines Capacity 2012-2017, UK to key country markets
*click here for a larger image*

Monarch-Blog-Table-2.jpgSource: OAG Schedules Analyser

The loss of some 3.7 million seats from the UK market will be a gap and most likely lead to some increase in yields for airlines; at least in the short-term as the market rebalances. However, more than anything perhaps the passing of a Monarch is more reflective of the difficulties of being a “mid-market” carrier in a world of low-cost travel.

Topics: Airlines, Europe

John Grant

Written by John Grant

Subscribe to our blog

25 October 2021 Blog

Tracking the Aviation Recovery: Summer Is Over and the Winter Looks Much Better

The last week of the 2021 summer season brings the usual mix of changes in airline capacity, as some markets continue their recovery and others ...

20 October 2021 Webinar

Is a sustainable recovery on its way?

What does this mean for the aviation industry? Becca Rowland, Partner, Midas Aviation, John Grant, Chief Analyst, are joined by our own in-house ...

24 June 2021 Podcast

OAG On Air: in conversation with Gregg Brunson-Pitts, Founder & President at Advanced Aviation Team

In this latest podcast, John Grant talks to Gregg Brunson-Pitts who is Founder & President at Advanced Aviation Team - a private jet charter ...